Test drive Audi Q5 3.0 TDI quattro against BMW X3 xDrive 30d: ndani amameza madzi?

BMW posakhalitsa idakulitsa masanjidwe a injini ya X3 yokhala ndi 258-lita ya dizilo yokhala ndi 5 hp. Kodi kusunthaku kungapindulitse kuposa Audi Q3.0 XNUMX TDI Quattro?

Malo opitilira muyeso, chilolezo pansi, kuzama kwakukulu kwa choletsa madzi ... Ndipo nayi kuya kovomerezeka. Zolemba malire 500 millimeters. Zokwanira. Ndi bwino kuwoloka mitsinje ing'onoing'ono ndi mitsinje yosaya, yomwe nthawi zambiri imapezeka m'misewu yamapiri. Chovuta chachikulu pankhaniyi atha kukhala kukayikira komveka kwa eni ake a X3 ndi Q5 aku Bavaria kuponyera kukongola kwawo m'madzi akuda ndikuwononga mawilo okongola a 18-inchi a aluminiyamu omwe Audi ndi BMW akukonzekeretsa mitundu iyi. mitundu yawo ya SUV. Osanenapo za kuopsa kokanda pa ma bumpers opukutidwa ndi lacquered ndikufunika koyeretsa pambuyo pake.

Kuyeza mphamvu

Kutali ndi dothi ndi misampha, mitundu iwiri yapamwamba ya SUV ilibe chodetsa nkhawa. Madizilo asanu ndi limodzi ali ndi mphamvu yopitilira malita atatu ndi mikhalidwe yofananira ndi mphamvu ndi torque - 258 hp. ndi 560 Nm kwa X3 ndi 240 hp. motsatira. ndi 500 Nm pa Q5. Ndi manambala ngati amenewo, mathamangitsidwe abwino komanso kukopa kwamphamvu kumatsimikizika, ngakhale mukakwera mapiri otsetsereka, Q5 imataya chitsogozo cha X3 xDrive 30d yatsopano. Injini yake yapakatikati ya silinda sikisi imakankhira SUV ya 1925 kilograms mosavuta kotero kuti mtundu wolemera wa 47 kilogalamu wa Audi uyenera kulimbikira kuti usagwere m'maso.

Mu 180 km / h sprint pa X3, zimatenga Q5 kupitilira masekondi atatu, ndipo zimawonekeratu kuti Ingolstadt V-galimoto silingapikisane ndikusalala kwa mdani wake wanthawi zonse kuthamanga kwambiri. Kutonthoza kwakung'ono kwa Audi ndikuti dizilo ya BMW pomwepo imawonetsa mawu owopsa mosayembekezeka, pomwe injini ya Q3 singazindikiridwe kuti ndi dizilo ngakhale ikamamvedwa kwambiri. Atafika pa liwiro lofunidwa pamsewu, magwiridwe antchito am'magawo awiriwo amapita kumbuyo, ndipo amasiya kukutengani, akuchita bwino ntchito yawo pafupifupi 2000 rpm.

Zochita ndi Zochita

Pomaliza, ma transmissions a stock automatic amathandizanso kuti pakhale ntchito yabwino komanso yabata. Ngakhale malingaliro osiyana ndi mapangidwe - kufala kwa ma XNUMX-speed-speed dual-clutch transmission mu Audi ndi gearbox wamba eyiti-liwiro mu BMW - njira zonse zimagwira ntchito mofananamo ndi kusinthasintha, kusuntha kolondola komanso kusankha zida zoyenera nthawi zonse. Kutumiza konseko ndi kwanzeru ndipo (pafupifupi nthawi zonse) kumathandiza wokwerayo kukhalabe mugiya munthawi yake ngati pakufunika, kapena kutsika masitepe awiri kapena atatu pansi pazigawo zotsetsereka.

Timachoka mumsewu waukulu n’kukaima pamalo oyamba mumzindawo. Mu BMW X3, mtendere ndi bata zimatsimikiziridwa nthawi yomweyo ndi dongosolo la Start-Stop. Chotsatiracho chimagwira ntchito yake mwakhama komanso mosalekeza, kutseka injini pa mwayi woyamba - kuyimitsa kawirikawiri ndikuyamba kukhumudwitsa anthu okhudzidwa kwambiri, koma ndithudi ali ndi ubwino wake, monga momwe ulendo wathu wopita kumalo opangira mafuta unasonyezera mwamsanga. Avereji ya malita asanu ndi anayi panjira yayikulu yoyeserera ndi 6,6L/100km panjira yotsika mtengo yamafuta ya AMS ndi manambala abwino kwambiri amtundu wofananira wa dual-gearbox. Audi Q5, yomwe 3.0 TDI sichipezeka mophatikizana ndi Start-Stop system, iyenera kukhala nthawi yayitali pamalo opangira 9,9 motsatana. 7,3 L / 100 Km. Kuipa uku kumakhudza mwachibadwa mlingo wa Q5 mu gawo lazokhudza chilengedwe.

Pamalo otaya zinyalala

Matanki adzazanso, ndipo kufananitsa kungapitirire - tikuyembekezera madera omwe ali ndi matembenuzidwe ambiri ndi malo osagwirizana. Ponseponse, okwera mayeso ayenera kukhala okonzekera bwino izi chifukwa cha kuyimitsidwa kwa damper, komwe kumapezeka pofunsidwa mu X3 ndi Q5. Kuphatikiza apo, mtundu wa BMW uli ndi chiwongolero chamasewera chokhala ndi mawonekedwe osinthika kutengera mawonekedwe agalimoto ndi mbiri yamsewu. N'zotheka kuti kuwonjezera pa zipangizo muyezo ndi ngongole yaikulu kwa X3 mwayi mu gawo ili, chifukwa ndi ngodya kukwera mofulumira mu gawo osankhidwa, chitsanzo Audi anatidabwitsa ndi chizolowezi oyambirira understeer ndi noticeable mphamvu thirakiti mitsempha. pakugwira ntchito kwa chiwongolero.

X3 imakhala ndimakhalidwe osalowerera ndale, osangalatsa, komanso osakhazikika, oyendetsa bwino kwambiri magudumu, ndipo imakhala yolimba pamsewu. Mulimonse momwe zingakhalire, magalimoto onsewa amapereka njira yoyendetsa kwambiri kuposa momwe munthu angafunire kapena kufunsa. Kuphatikiza apo, m'malo ovuta, amatha kudalira makina awo otetezedwa bwino omwe ali ndi kuthekera koyenera, kofatsa koma kokhazikika pakufunika kutero. Kuyenda bwino kwa ma braking system ndi ma airbags asanu ndi limodzi kuyeneranso kuwunikiridwa. Mtundu wa Audi wayamba kale kukhala wachikulire, koma, mosiyana ndi mnzake waku Munich, amapereka mwayi wokhazikitsa njira zothandizila oyendetsa magalimoto kuti zisinthe ndikusintha msewu.

Pankhani ya chitonthozo

Pofuna kutonthoza dalaivala ndi okwera, samalani mipando yokhala ndi zikopa (pamtengo wowonjezera) zomwe zimapereka chithandizo chokwanira cham'mbali komanso kutonthoza pamipando yonse. Kuphatikiza apo, mipando ya BMW imakhala ndi chothandizira chowonjezerapo mchiuno komanso chopingasa chosanja chamagetsi.

Okwera otsika amatha kulola kuyimitsidwa kosinthika kumagwira ntchito yake ngati yanthawi zonse ndikusangalala ndi chitonthozo chapamwamba komanso kuwongolera kotetezeka, kupangitsa Q5 ndi X3 kuyendetsa mopanda nkhawa ngakhale mtunda wautali. Danga mu kanyumba ya zitsanzo ziwiri za SUVs ndi yotamandika, ndi mitengo ikuluikulu ochezeka katundu ndi za kukula chomwecho - 550 ndi 540 malita, motero.

Mtundu wa Audi umalandila zowonjezerapo pamachitidwe ake potengera kulipira, mawonekedwe a oyendetsa komanso magwiridwe antchito amkati. Kumbuyo kwa mpando wakumbuyo kumatha kupendekeka mu Q5, ndipo mulingo wokhalapo wautali wa mamilimita 100 ulipo. BMW imatsutsana ndi kukoka matani 2,4 ndi chipinda chothandizira pansi pa nsapato. Ndipo popeza X3 ndi Q5 akuyembekezeredwa kuti azigwiranso ntchito mofananira malinga ndi magwiridwe antchito ndi mtundu wake, mtundu wa Ingolstadt umapambana gawo lowerengera thupi.

Ubwino uli ndi mtengo

Ulemerero wonsewu umabwera pamtengo wake. Audi ikupempha BGN 3.0 osachepera 87 TDI Quattro, pamene BMW imangofunsa BGN 977 zambiri za 7523bhp yamphamvu kwambiri. galimoto. Onse awiri ali ndi zipangizo zokhazikika, kuphatikizapo makina omvera omwe ali ndi CD player, mpweya wokhazikika, malo ambiri osungiramo zinthu zing'onozing'ono m'nyumba, ndi mawilo a aluminium 18 inchi. Zofuna zina zonse ziyenera kutsogoleredwa ndi mndandanda wa zida zowonjezera, zomwe, mwa njira, ndizofanana ndi zitsanzo zonse ziwiri. Ndipo tsatanetsatane womaliza - mitundu yonse ya SUV idalimbana ndi chotchinga chamadzi popanda vuto ...

lemba: Michael von Maidel

chithunzi: Hans-Dieter Zeifert

kuwunika

1. BMW X3 xDrive 30d - 519 points

Injini yamphamvu kwambiri koma yodula dizilo idathandizira kwambiri pakupambana kwa kanyumba kakang'ono ka X3. Palibe amene angakane makhalidwe abwino oyendetsera bwino komanso kuyimitsidwa bwino kwambiri. Ergonomics ndi magwiridwe antchito sizimatsutsa. Potengera mtengo wapansi komanso mtengo wazida zina, X3 ndi Q5 zili pafupi kwambiri.

2. Audi Q5 3.0 TDI quattro - 507 mfundo

Kukula kwakukulu komanso kwabwino ngati njira yachitetezo, Q5 imakakamizidwa kuvomereza pakuwunika kwabwino kwa omwe akupikisana nawo kuchokera ku BMW. Zifukwa zabodzazi zili mu injini yowopsa kwambiri, chiwongolero cha jittery ndi phokoso lomwe limafikira m'makutu a okwera mukamayendetsa m'malo osadziwika bwino. Kutayika kwa mtunduwo kuchokera ku Ingolstadt ndikuyenera kuyimbidwanso chifukwa chogwiritsa ntchito mafuta pagawo loyesa la APP komanso kuneneratu za kugulitsa kotsika kumsika wachiwiri.

Zambiri zaukadaulo

1. BMW X3 xDrive 30d - 519 points	2. Audi Q5 3.0 TDI quattro - 507 mfundo
Ntchito voliyumu	-	-
Kugwiritsa ntchito mphamvu	Zamgululi 258 ks pa 4000 rpm	Zamgululi 240 ks pa 4000 rpm
Kuchuluka makokedwe	-	-
Kupititsa patsogolo 0-100 km / h	6,3 s	7,0 s
Ma braking mtunda pa liwiro la 100 km / h	38 m	37 m
Kuthamanga kwakukulu	230 km / h	225 km / h
Kuchuluka kwa mowa mafuta pamayeso	9,0 l	9,9 l
Mtengo Woyamba	95 500 levov	87 977 levov

Kunyumba " Zolemba " Zopanda kanthu » Audi Q5 3.0 TDI quattro vs BMW X3 xDrive 30d: ndani ameza madzi?